e.l.f.Lash 'N Roll Mascara, Curling Mascara For Visibly Lifted Lashes, Lifts & Separates Lashes. Long-Lasting Formula, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Pitch Black

I ordered this and e.l.f. Lash XTNDR Mascara at the same time. They both got good reviews on Makeup Alley, so I wanted to compare them. I first tried the Lash XTNDR and loved it, my review is here: https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R1IXHQB5YL052Q?ie=UTF8&ASIN=B0CPFXVC1SWhen I put this Lash 'N Roll on, I was confused as it looked and felt the same as Lash XTNDR, although this is not advertised as a tubing mascara like Lash XTNDR. It even has the same brush, the brown color is the same, the containers are the same shape, the only difference is the color of the cap.. It performed the same way that Lash XTNDR did. One day I wore one on my right eye, the other on my left, no difference all day. Finally I looked up the ingredients, they are the same!I wonder how many other cosmetic companies do this, especially ones like e.l.f. that make low-cost dupes of more expensive products? Anyway, it's good to know if e.l.f. ever discontinues one of these that there is a perfect substitute. In the meantime, I will buy whichever version has the best price at the time.So my review is the same as the one on Lash XTNDR. Another holy grail mascara!

This is the dupe for the mascara Benefit. I love benefit because it doesn’t make my lashes look clumpy, and I was looking for something similar and I saw Elf had this dupe so I bought it because it was only like 6 bucks. But it was definitely worth 6 bucks. They work almost the same! I will say though that Benefit is a little more volumized looking! But I’m definitely going to keep using this. 🩷

This is a subtle mascara which defines lashes and gives a little lift with multiple coats. I appreciate the reasonable price, however I noticed that after a couple weeks if use, not much mascara is on the brush. I have to put the wand back in for enough product several times when applying. It also seems to be drying out.

As I have aged, my lashes have gotten thinner and sparse. Trying to find a mascara that works well for me has been a serious challenge until now. This e.l.f. Lash 'N Roll Mascara is absolutely the best I've found in years. Eyelashes separate beautifully and coverage is consistent across every lash. I've had no flaking or smudging. Impressed and truly surprised as how well this stuff works at its low price. Highly recommend!

I am never without this mascara. I buy it over and over again. It is my everyday go to and it never fails. The formula is excellent. It lasts for hours and it doesn't flake. I love the natural but polished look of my lashes with this one. I do not wear false lashes, they irritate my eyes and this mascara gives me a lot of volume and it separates my lashes very well. I put on top a coat of the Loreal Telescopic and voila...false lashes look without the false lashes 🤩. I hope elf never discontinues it because it is truly perfect.

Elf is my go to makeup products however I don't care much for the mascara. It goes on clumpy and definitely doesn't give you much volume (unless you like clumpy eyelashes 😆) it does last long if you can get past the clumps 😆 I probably won't be purchasing it again for myself however my daughter does like it. That's why I gave it 3 stars due to mixed reviews between the 2 of us ❤️

This mascara is a WIN. Ot does not flake. I was shocked by the hard silicone type brush the first time I used it, but i love the brush. If you ask me, the brush makes the mascara. This does don't clump due to the type of brush and my lashes look great. All day wear and it removes very easily. Highly recommend! Will definitely buy again and again

OMG I LOVEEEEEEE this mascara! It definitely fills in great without needing fake lashes! Def pops! A keeper for sure!!! I don't want to wear fake lashes and this really helps A LOT! This is very similar to the wet n wild mascara here (https://amzn.to/42Hef23)